COMMENTARY: Basic American Principles Confuse Liberals

Comment   Email   Print
Related Articles
Principles are important - without them we get off track and lose our way. Many believe that our federal government has lost its way while others just don't understand why so many object to the "change" taking place today.

The foundational principles of American government are the principles that made our nation great - America is about freedom.

* The purpose of our government is to secure our rights.

The Declaration of Independence established the American view of the rights of man and the duties of government. "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed." They concluded by stating that our "separate but equal station" with Britain and other governments of the world would give us "full power to levy war, conclude peace, contract alliances, establish commerce, and to do all other acts and things which independent states may of right do."

Our Constitution, drafted in 1787, used the Declaration of Independence as a guide to governance. The Constitution up-holds the purpose of our government, to secure our rights, and provides seventeen specific powers to the federal government in Article 1, Section 8. Two years later a Bill of Rights was added by the states in order to prevent misconstruction and abuse of federal powers; succeeding amendments bring the total number of enumerated federal powers to 30. None of those 30 powers grant general legislative authority to the federal government. In fact, such powers belong only to the states; called police powers - states pass laws to secure the rights of individuals.

So what they created is the freest county in the world - with a government that recognizes mans' unalienable rights, and whose purpose is to secure those rights for its citizens'. In the United States, all have freedom and all understand that we can express our freedoms until we infringe upon another's freedom. Except where individual actions may infringe on the unalienable and Constitutional rights of another, our government is to stay out of the affairs of the people and of business.

* Our government cannot take-away or infringe on our rights

Our nation, our Constitutional Republic is based upon natural rights. But just what are unalienable rights and Constitutional rights? An unalienable right is a natural right granted to man by our Creator; described ever so simply as life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness in our Declaration of Independence and it is also a Constitutional right. Life is, well, life. Examples of liberty are freedom to believe, or become, or protect yourself; a right to your speech, your reputation, and the things you create. Pursuit of happiness is freedom to make your own way, own your own property or live anywhere; a right to what you earn.

Constitutional rights such as trial by jury, to bear arms and vote don't seem natural. They are not natural, but they do serve to directly secure our natural rights. For instance, who judges our actions is very important because we can lose our liberty as punishment. Arms are not natural - but protecting yourself, especially from your own government, is a natural right. Therefore, the right to bear arms serves to secure your natural rights. The right to vote protects your right to self-determination and liberty, even speech. All in all, unalienable or Constitutional, our rights are rights which no government can take-away, question or alter, they are unalienable. No social contract can cause us to surrender these rights.

* Rights are of no cost to anyone else

My freedom of speech costs you nothing. Your freedom of religion costs me nothing.

The liberal error; confusing needs with rights; confusing positive and negative

What liberals tend to do is to believe that they can "create" rights out of needs and then demand those rights from the government in the form of services - such as for health care. The liberals' major mistake is that they not only misunderstand what rights are but they also misinterpret rights as "positive rights" - in other words, that the government has an obligation to provide a particular right to each citizen.

For example, we have laws against crime, and in the past there have been times when citizens have sued the government because the police didn't arrive in time to prevent that crime. While you have a natural right not to be harmed, there is no right to expect that the government will prevent you from becoming a victim of a crime; the government is not at any fault or liability in this instance.

Liberals need to understand that rights are natural and negative. There cannot be a natural right to health care. Making health care a right requires infringing upon your rights and the rights of others. Aches and pains are natural but there is no natural right that someone must tend to your every ache or pain. To take resources (money, labor or goods) from one to give to another violates our natural right to our own property. For the government to force you to buy something that is not for the purpose of protecting the rights of another, such as liability car insurance, is a taking of your property in direct violation of your rights.

* America is about freedom

Defending our nation from foreign invaders, serving justice through the courts and constructing an orderly monetary and bankruptcy system are enumerated powers in the Constitution. Each of those federal powers helps to secure the continuance of our government, our liberty and our property. Government financing of health care is not an enumerated power of the federal government nor is health care a natural right.

In fact today, the federal government does thousands of things not enumerated in the Constitution - and although it has become customary in Washington, this is why millions object. You can't fundamentally change the fact that the whole point and most unique feature of our American government is that the government cannot infringe or take-away our natural, unalienable or Constitutional rights.

Federal legislators have had a good time through the 20th and now 21st century infringing on the states, and satisfying the Liberals by creating all kinds of programs and laws that spend trillions and trillions of dollars, all of it at direct expense to individual freedom and liberty and states' rights.

What most of us want liberals to understand is that the most important basic principle of our American government is - America is about freedom. The citizen is in charge. He is not just a funding source for the federal legislators' - there are limits to federal power and purpose. It is the American people that have always solved the problems of our nation - and we must be free in order to continue to do so.

Rep. Susan Lynn
Chairman, Government Operations Committee
215 War Memorial Building
Nashville, TN 37243
Read more from:
Comment   Email   Print
Members Opinions:
December 25, 2009 at 10:08am
December 25, 2009 at 9:23pm
Susan Lynn For President!!!!! She has my vote. If we don't QUICKLY get some people in Washington who have some logic and common sense and who are not afraid to stand up and defend our Constitution then this Country and us as free Americans are doomed.
December 27, 2009 at 5:35pm
This is also a Christian nation. Would Christ

A) Perpetuate a system wherein only the economically or occupationally privileged can afford health care


B) Encourage and facilitate meaningful reform that helps makes health care affordable to children and adults of all economic standings?

I wonder if Rep. Lynn realizes how selfish and trivial her arguments against reform are.
December 28, 2009 at 10:10am
The more people are GIVEN things on a regular basis, the less likely they will take responsibility for themselves. Please tell me how that providing a system that gives healthcare to some people who don't work and punishing the people that do work is fair. Free Healthcare is NOT a right designated in our Constitution. It is a person's responsibility to decide if they want to purchase healthcare for themselves and their family, maybe in leiu of other things that they consider important - like cable tv, cigarettes, eating out multiple times a week, etc. If the government would stop trying to be in the healthcare business,and put some reasonable regulations on Insurance Companies and Medicare, then the free market system would soon balance out our insurance problems. The problem is, the only way the Government can control the citizens of this country is to control our healthcare, our food supply, our energy supply, etc. We are no longer a free nation of independent citizens when everything we have to have is supplied by government control.
December 28, 2009 at 2:46pm
What a shame that Susan knows so little about what the constitution set forward in the summer of 1787.
WE had a system of governing that enslaved the Negroes, deprived the Indians of any naturals rights to their land and deprived non-property holders of their votes along with a complete disenfranchizing of women.
It was only through changes to those imprefect documents that this nation rose to be a beacon of freedom. We must continue on that path that gave us Social Security, Medicare, Voting Rights of the 60s just to name a few of the great social reforms--and now, flawed though it may be --health care reform.
Susan reminds of the Dixiecrats of old!
What drivel.
December 28, 2009 at 3:04pm
Liberal pie in the sky versus Conservative logic and common sense -- and never the twain shall meet!!! Pray for America.
Powered by Bondware
News Publishing Software

The browser you are using is outdated!

You may not be getting all you can out of your browsing experience
and may be open to security risks!

Consider upgrading to the latest version of your browser or choose on below: