Problem Solved: Dirty Rooms and Falling Ceilings

Nov 16, 2026 at 04:45 am by admin


Bob Burfeind’s dream vacation in Cancun turns into a nomadic nightmare of dirty rooms and falling ceilings. After three moves in five nights and a lackluster response from Super.com, he wants a refund. 

 

Q: I had a confirmed hotel reservation for the Petit Lafitte Resort in Playa del Carmen, Mexico, recently. I verified the booking several times through both Super.com, the booking site I used to make the reservation, and the resort itself. 

However, when we arrived, the hotel claimed our reservation didn't start for another three days. They told us we’d been notified of the change, but we never received any email.The resort eventually found us an alternative at another hotel about 20 minutes away. They assured us it was of "equal value, if not a step up." 

It was anything but. 

The hotel was a clear downgrade. Our room was dirty, the soaking pool was ill-kept, and we had no hot water. To make matters worse, several electrical problems plagued the room, which was situated over a noisy bar with a view of a rusty tin roof.

The situation became dangerous during the night when a large piece of the ceiling fell into our bathtub. We demanded a new room, which they gave us, but we had to move our own luggage. 

Over a five-night stay, we were forced to make three different moves. We wasted a significant portion of our vacation just trying to find a habitable place to sleep. We’ve asked both Super.com and Petit Lafitte for a full refund of $1,056. The only thing Petit Lafitte offered was a one-night stay toward a future visit, which we have no intention of using. 

Super.com has given us nothing. Can you help us get our money back? —Bob Burfeind, Minneapolis

A: When a hotel or a booking site confirms a reservation, it has a duty of care to provide the room you paid for. If it can't, it should "walk" you to a comparable property, which is hotel-speak for finding you a room at a comparable property for the same price.

A property with falling ceilings and no hot water is not a step up—it's a safety and sanitation hazard. Under most hotel industry standards and consumer protection norms, if a resort provides a significantly inferior experience or a dangerous environment, you're entitled to more than a voucher for a future stay you'll never use. You deserve either a partial or a full refund.

You did the right thing by documenting your hotel disaster. Taking pictures of the dirty pool and the ceiling in the bathtub is essential for any successful dispute. You also kept a paper trail, which is the most important tool in any consumer's arsenal.

For future reference, if a company ignores your initial request, you can always escalate your complaint. I list the contact information for Super.com and many major hotel chains and travel providers on my consumer advocacy site, Elliott.org. 

I contacted Super.com on your behalf and shared the details of your case. In a message to you, Super.com acknowledged that "a number of mistakes were made," and it agreed to issue a full refund of $1,056. I'm glad my advocacy team and I could help you close the door on this hotel nightmare.

 

Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy (https://elliottadvocacy.org), a nonprofit organization that helps consumers solve their problems. Email him at chris@elliott.org or get help by contacting him at https://elliottadvocacy.org/help/

 

 Christopher Elliott is the founder of Elliott Advocacy (https://elliottadvocacy.org), a nonprofit organization that helps consumers solve their problems. Email him at chris@elliott.org or get help by contacting him at https://elliottadvocacy.org/help/

Sections: COURIER SPOTLIGHT